Results from Tuesday’s judicial primaries for all circuits outside of Cook

Here are the results for Tuesday's judicial primaries for all circuits outside of Cook. Click the link below for the list of results from around the state with ISBA ratings for each candidate.

Winners in bold

  • Click here for the results from Tuesday's Supreme and Appellate primaries
  • Click here for the results from Tuesday's Cook County Circuit primaries

(R) Republican
(D) Democrat

Candidates must receive 65% on the question of Meets Requirements of Office in order to be Recommended.

1st Circuit - Williamson County - Eckiss

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Smoot (R) 82.65 96.97 93.94 74.49 96.97 83.33 96.84 96.97
McNeill (D) 67.07 86.75 76.83 64.63 76.83 81.25 98.77 84.34
Kochan (D) 40.91 53.41 43.68 45.45 54.65 61.90 94.12 67.44

2nd Circuit - Circuitwide - Vantrease

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Dirnbeck (D)* 98.46 98.46 95.38 93.85 96.92 98.44 96.92 96.88
Parrish (D) 58.46 62.50 69.84 70.77 83.08 68.25 93.65 82.54
Swofford (D) 38.46 54.55 52.63 64.10 39.74 55.26 77.63 56.58
Renshaw (D) 20.83 52.05 48.61 22.97 49.32 34.72 76.81 59.15
Newcomb (D) 13.51 30.14 55.71 18.92 50.68 11.27 68.57 69.01

*Dirnbeck has been named the unofficial winner. Absentee ballots are still being counted and the official winner will be named April 13.

2nd Circuit - Jefferson County - Gamber

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Piercy (D) 95.16 98.39 96.77 93.55 95.16 96.72 98.39 98.39
Weber (D) 79.37 98.41 90.48 66.67 90.48 90.32 98.41 96.77
Hanson (D) 72.73 82.95 74.71 82.02 80.90 75.28 96.55 88.76
Villani (R) 68.83 69.62 58.97 81.01 72.15 85.33 93.67 74.67

2nd Circuit - White County - Sutton

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Webb (R) 94.29 97.14 97.22 100.00 94.44 97.22 100.00 94.44
Blades (D) 54.90 78.00 76.00 54.90 74.51 64.71 94.12 92.16

3rd Circuit - Circuitwide - Romani

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Napp (D) 92.76 96.00 89.40 94.67 94.04 96.05 100.00 94.63
Burkhart (R) 46.39 70.83 60.64 51.52 47.37 64.37 90.32 75.82
Rabe (R)  ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

4th Circuit - Shelby County - Kiley

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Bennett (R) 76.36 98.21 94.55 75.00 96.43 76.79 85.71 96.36
Nohren (D) 70.30 85.44 76.70 80.77 66.02 94.17 97.09 87.25

5th Circuit - Coles County - Jacobs

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
O'Brien 96.67 96.72 96.72 98.36 96.72 100.00 98.36 96.72

6th Circuit - Circuitwide - Paine

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Griffith 97.40 98.72 97.44 98.72 98.72 100.00 100.00 100.00

7th Circuit - Circuitwide - Appleton

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Schmidt (R) 83.42 89.34 80.00 86.15 88.32 93.97 93.94 90.40
Londrigan (D) 75.68 84.11 75.33 85.23 84.56 88.59 98.01 92.72

7th Circuit - Scott County - Bell

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Coonrod (D) 73.21 87.72 81.13 81.82 87.72 70.37 100.00 89.09
Cherry (R) 71.70 83.33 74.07 89.09 78.18 79.63 96.30 81.48
Crews (R) 69.64 85.19 78.85 67.27 79.63 74.55 90.91 79.63

8th Circuit - Pike County - Roseberry

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
McCartney 82.86 91.67 82.86 88.57 94.44 94.29 100.00 88.57

9th Circuit - Warren County - McClintock

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Baber (R) 82.61 93.48 84.78 86.96 80.43 86.96 95.65 86.96
Standard (R) 57.14 84.29 70.59 92.88 47.14 82.88 87.14 75.71

9th Circuit - Hancock County - Stoverink

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Clark 86.00 94.00 89.58 87.76 88.00 87.76 100.00 89.80

10th Circuit - Circuitwide - Shadid

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Gorman (R) 96.49 98.61 97.56 95.45 97.21 98.61 100.00 98.95
Spanos (D) 92.12 97.06 94.58 94.63 94.61 91.96 96.52 95.05
Hoppock (R) 16.15 41.40 22.98 21.60 20.37 46.20 74.07 31.01

10th Circuit - Peoria County - Grawey

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Lyons 65.37 81.78 70.77 81.01 62.40 59.92 95.35 81.18

11th Circuit - Circuitwide - Prall

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Lawrence (R) 95.10 96.53 95.14 93.71 97.22 97.90 98.60 97.90
Gramm (R) 25.30 65.85 44.58 29.27 65.85 61.25 88.75 56.10

11th Circuit - McLean County - Souk

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Foley 95.31 98.45 97.67 96.06 96.12 99.22 100.00 98.45

13th Circuit - LaSalle County - Lanuti

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Holland (R) 78.67 94.67 89.33 77.33 93.33 89.33 96.00 90.67
Kopko (D) 59.67 81.71 70.37 64.63 75.61 81.71 91.46 82.93

15th Circuit - Circuitwide - Pemberton

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Hanson 96.00 96.00 94.00 100.00 96.00 100.00 98.00  

16th Circuit - Kane County - Colwell

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Barsanti 91.84 94.95 87.88 97.97 90.95 95.41 97.42 91.33

16th Circuit - 2nd Subcircuit - Judgeship A

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Walters (R) 59.65 74.78 78.57 58.41 79.31 71.56 88.99 72.81
Hurlbut (R) 45.83 67.12 58.57 47.22 68.57 63.64 81.43 64.29
Dalton ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

17th Circuit - 3rd Subcircuit - Judgeship A

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Maher 94.51 97.80 95.58 95.56 97.79 95.58 99.45 97.78

18th Circuit - Circuitwide - Thompson

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
McKillip (R) 94.40 97.75 96.93 97.49 90.56 95.77 100.00 95.80
Gibson (R) 93.62 97.53 96.10 92.23 96.83 94.89 97.83 95.70
O'Shea (R) 34.35 51.16 44.53 40.91 52.71 56.52 83.33 54.47
Wilson (D)                

19th Circuit - 2nd Subcircuit - Judgeship A

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Berrones (R) 94.49 97.66 94.49 96.06 92.91 96.88 98.44 96.03
Fix (D) 47.37 74.67 59.21 61.84 60.00 77.03 88.00 78.08

19th Circuit - 3rd Subcircuit - Judgeship A

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Shanes (R) 92.98 95.58 90.35 98.25 94.74 99.12 99.12 94.74
Braiman (D)                

19th Circuit - 3rd Subcircuit - Judgeship B

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Schippers (R) 88.68 97.14 87.74 95.28 94.34 99.06 99.06 94.34
Waites (D) 81.40 93.85 86.05 82.17 77.52 91.54 95.38 89.23
Projansky ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

20th Circuit - Washington County - Hatch

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Trentman (D) 88.19 91.61 89.51 93.66 90.21 92.14 96.45 91.43
Kozuszek (R) 67.92 77.36 73.58 67.92 79.25 75.00 96.00 77.55
Emge (R) ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

20th Circuit - Circuitwide - O'Malley

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Lopinot (D) 95.06 97.11 93.78 97.51 97.53 97.51 99.58 96.65
Duebbert (R) 37.19 57.76 55.26 52.59 54.31 53.70 83.93 71.05

20th Circuit - Circuitwide - Wharton

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Cruse (D) 78.03 91.72 81.55 75.45 84.80 85.80 96.97 91.12
Cason (R) 41.20 72.04 65.88 41.98 70.56 51.42 80.29 76.56
Keeley (D) 30.95 69.05 60.24 28.92 57.65 43.21 81.93 68.29

20th Circuit - St. Clair County - Cueto

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Gleeson 93.98 94.38 90.24 97.97 96.36 97.98 99.59 98.37

23rd Circuit - DeKalb County - Klein

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Matekaitis (D) 84.62 90.57 82.69 75.47 94.23 88.48 98.11 92.45
Brady (R) 84.00 98.00 82.35 96.15 84.62 64.71 100.00 84.62

23rd Circuit - Kendall County - Judgeship A

Candidate Meets Requirements Integrity Impartiality Legal Ability Temperament Court Management Health Sensitivity
Barnhart (R) 96.15 96.23 98.11 96.23 96.23 98.11 100.00 94.34
Kim (R) ** ** ** ** ** ** ** **

 

Posted on March 21, 2012 by Chris Bonjean

Login to post comments